The Tired Old Comparison: Austin versus Dallas


“OMG you’re moving to Austin!!!”

 “I wish I was you, Austin is such an amazing place”

 “Finally getting out of Dallas huh”

  4 months ago, I decided to “uproot” (I say that because its not like I moved to another state) my life and move from Dallas (plano) the home I had called for 24ish years and move to the state capitol of Texas, Austin.

 Everywhere you look, Austin is on a list. “Best Places to Live” “Happiest Towns” “Best Cities for the Next Decade” “Most amount of smelly hippies in the South” “ Best cities for business” Sometimes it’s number one, sometimes its number 5. Fact of the matter is, everyone loves Austin, and that’s what drew me to move down here- the idea of “Austin” and that it’s a cool city.

 There’s something about the ability to run on a sandy lake every day. Or going biking, hiking, or constantly going to large parks and seeing 500 sports being played. It’s not just Friday and Saturday that music goes on, but every day. It’s also fascinating seeing so many people in what used to be a college town, come from all over and help to build and create an “idea”.

 I finally became an official Austin resident two weeks ago. It’s been a nice run so far, and Austin is a great city, but the idea of “Austin” has begun to fade, and I’ve missed living in Dallas. Note that I said Dallas, and not Plano. Plano sucks, and it’s a horrible city unless you’re my parents. It’s flat, full of concrete, conservative, and just boring.

 Dallas is different. Yes, it has its pretentiousness. Yes, people do dress up to go to the gym of all places. Yes, prices could be lower in Uptown, and the city does struggle to create and identity for itself.

 Dallas does have character. It has pro sports. It has great restaurants. It’s diverse. It’s a great place for a corporation, and it’s a great place for a startup. It has its quirky neighborhoods, and if you want to include the metroplex as a whole, great music. But once again, the suburbs blow .

 I decided to do my own comparison of things I like to do- Dallas vs Austin, as well as general comparisons. Feel free to critique, but this is just how I see it. I’m leaving out institutions of higher learning because I’m out of college and frankly, TCU, UNT, UTA, SMU don’t compare to UT. I’m also leaving out traffic and road comparisons because the well-manicured roads and ability of Dallas to understand how to effectively build for growth on the roads pales in comparison to the inability of Austin to understand to positive effects of light rail and to effectively curb the constant problem of traffic that persists on days other than festivals. (Wait… you’re telling me a liberal city can’t figure out an effective public transportation solution?)

 Downtown Cityscape- Dallas: Reunion Tower, Corporate buildings, Omni, AAC, Margaret Hunt Bridge. It’s mainly Reunion tower, but it really has that big city feel as you drive in from 35.  Austin: Less corporate buildings, but its has Town Lake as part of its cityscape. That in itself distinguishes it. Advantage: Push

 Nightlife: Dallas:  Uptown, Downtown, Mockingbird, Lower Greenville, Shops at Legacy, Deep Ellum, Addison. Each has their own individual feel to it. Except Shops at Legacy sucks. Austin: Dirty 6th, West 6th, Warehouse District, Fourth Street, Rainey Street, the Arboretum, Numerous concerts (yes that counts). Both cities are great for nightlife. The “fratmosphere” that encompasses some areas of Austin definitely permeates in Dallas in Uptown and Greenville. Parking downtown blows in Austin. In Dallas, it isn’t so bad, but it’d be nice to have the car to gos they do here. Is Austin cheaper than Dallas? In some places they have great specials, but its getting more to be prices of a  typical cosmopolitan city. Advantage: Push

Outdoors: Dallas: Katy Trail, White Rock, various pools in apartment complexes, some parks. A decent start, but wayyyy too much concrete. Not enough bike paths, and really the Katy Trail is just one long strip of concrete. The ample amount of pools in Uptown makes it nice to sit and drink heavily on a weekend and view the Dallas skyline, but this is an area where Dallas lacks. The new park on Woodall Rogers will be a nice touch. Austin: This is where Austin takes the cake. Town Lake> Katy Trail, numerous hike and bike paths, Greenbelt, Barton Hills, Zilker. You wont find a Dallas park at 9 am spawning with activity unless its suburban soccer leagues. There’s parks everywhere. The only problem is a lack of pickup basketball unless you join a gym. Advantage: Austin

Sports Teams: Dallas: The Rangers and Cowboys are in Arlington. Whatever. A championship parade will still be in Dallas, because Arlington is a terrible city. The Dallas Mavericks and Dallas Stars share the AAC. FC Dallas plays in nearby Frisco. There are a number of minor league teams in the area. NASCAR at TMS. Lone Star Park. Dallas is a great sports town. Austin: Sorry, but UT does not count as a pro team. I don’t care how much revenue they make or how good the football team is, it is not a Pro team. Neither are the Austin Toros. And the Round Rock Express, the Rangers Triple A team, actually isn’t that great, since most of the players actually bypass Triple A from Frisco (Mike Olt). Will Austin ever be a good pro sports town? Who knows, its has F1 coming in November, but even that is contentious. Advantage: Dallas

 

Diversity/People: Much is said about both cities people. “Dallas people are snobby” “Austinites are soooo laid back” “Austinites are welcoming” “Dallas is for rich people”. Yes, there are people in Dallas who are absolute snobs (West Plano, Park Cities, even some Downtown) and yes, there are some really cool people in Austin. But don’t you think a shirt that says “Don’t Dallas my Austin” is pretty snobby? Austinites think highly of themselves, and some scoff at you when you say you’re from Dallas. In fact, many new Austinites are disgruntled former Dallas residents. The reputation of Dallas may be snobby, but there are nice people all over. Check out a Saturday afternoon, by the pool and see the interesting people you meet. Check out a sporting event, where you cheer on a team along with thousands of other Dallassites. Check out a Dallassite, Mark Cuban, who saved the Greenville Avenue Parade because he understood what it meant to the partygoers of Dallas.

Austin is great, don’t get me wrong. There are plenty of young entrepreneurs who create events, organizations, and relationships that really help build Austin into not such a hippie-centric city, and one that really takes pride in the identity change it’s undergoing, from the “Slacker” move archetype, to the Southern Silicon Valley. Yes, some people say that change is bad for the city, and that Austin is losing what made it Austin. Every city undergoes a period of gentrification though, is this just the fast-tracking of the corporatization of Austin?

As stated before, Dallas is in a similar quandary. With the dearth of reality shows, and glitz and glamour, does Dallas want to position itself as Los Angeles or New York? Or is it the Dallas TV series, with larger than life cowboy personalities, and oilmen who strike it rich and move to the big city because well, who really wants to live in Midland/Odessa once you’ve made your money?

Due to my status as an Austin resident, I’m tied to the city for at least a year. Will I move back to Dallas at some point? I never thought I would, but I probably will, because it’s home. Would I like to live somewhere else before that happens? Yes, everyone should live out of their comfort zone for an extended period of time. Did I think I was going to make Austin my home for an extended period of time? Yes, although now it doesn’t seem so certain.

If you live in either of these cities just know it could be worse: You could live in Houston. 

Advertisements

11 responses to “The Tired Old Comparison: Austin versus Dallas

  1. Just read this comparison and loved your input. Then I realized we both frequent GMG when I saw your name lol. Random!

  2. Just wondering, are you still in Austin?

  3. How does shops at Legacy suck?

  4. Which city has a better climate? I am a disabled Veteran learning music and I am inerested in a future career in music. Which city has better oppurtunities in music? I play the piano and sing. Thanks for any input.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s